Microscopy and Image Analysis Buying Guide

Image analysis and microscopy is a diverse and progressing topic, used by many scientists in settings from school and university labs to groundbreaking scientific labs. This guide aims to offer guidance for both new and existing users of microscopy and image analysis equipment.
Visiting manufacturer websites is a good place to gather technical product information for specific techniques. Case studies, application notes and technical data is freely available, particularly on sites such as Andor, Nikon, Carl Zeiss Olympus, Leica and SelectScience. There are many guides detailing the basic concepts of microscopy and the science behind optical, electron and scanning microscopy.
In recent years these have been further developed to subheadings such as fluorescence, confocal, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM) to name but a few. These sub heading have been further developed to include some specialist techniques for live cell imaging, digital microscopy, polarized light microscopy, X-ray fluorescence, laser scanning for example.
The topic is broad and detailed. This buying guide gives a brief overview of the current techniques involved in microscopy, and highlights the emerging trends, how these assist labs with research and what we can expect from the future.
Microscopy Technology in Brief
New techniques are developing all the time, as scientists push the boundaries in science ever forward, solutions to imaging problems are solved with newly developed techniques. Here is a look at some of the techniques known to us presently.
Optical Microscopy
| Sub-Category | Techniques | Description | |
|
Transmitted
Light |
Brightfield |
Allows
visualization of unstained samples. |
|
|
Darkfield |
Fine
structures become visible, with side illumination. |
||
|
Phase
Contrast |
Ideal
for biomedical research of unstained living cells. |
||
|
VAREL
Contrast |
Ideal
for examination of living cells in culture vessels. |
||
|
Polarization
Contrast |
Using
this method, polarized light is used; it consists of light waves which all
feature the same direction of vibration, i.e. which are linearly polarized |
||
|
Differential Interference Contrast (DIC) |
Contrasting
technique |
||
|
Reflected-light |
Brightfield |
Good
for examining structure of metal samples, surface of ceramics and printed
paper. |
|
|
Darkfield |
Ideal
for the inspection of surfaces. |
||
|
Polarization
Contrast (POL) |
Suitable
for surfaces with structures which change the state of polarization during
reflection, e.g. structure grains in samples of ore. |
||
|
Differential Interference Contrast (DIC) |
As an
extension of polarization contrast, this method also allows the visualization
of minute elevation differences in surfaces. i.e. Brass |
||
|
Confocal |
Confocal Laser Scanning (CLSM) |
Small
slices from microscopic samples are generated. The sample stays intact and
the slicing maybe repeated many times. Signals pass back to a detector. |
|
|
True Confocal Scanning (TCS) |
One
diffraction limited spot is illuminated and observed. |
||
|
Coherent
Anti-Stokes Raman Spectroscopy (CARS) |
Dye-free
method. Images structures by rapid vibrational
imaging of living cells. |
||
|
Fluorescence |
Super-resolution
Imaging |
Fluorescent
proteins are used to fluorescence living material. |
|
|
Total Internal
Reflection Fluorescence (TIRFM) |
Sensitive
technique which allows for functional investigation in living cells. |
||
|
Fluorescence-Lifetime
Imaging (FLIM) |
Measures
the decay rate of fluorescence to give a ‘lifetime’ signal as opposed to one
based on intensity. Used for receptor signaling. |
||
|
Fluorescence
Correlation Spectroscopy (FCS) |
Used to
examine the dynamics and concentration of fluorescent molecules in solution. |
||
|
Fluorescence
Cross-Correlation Spectroscopy (FCCS) |
Two
independently labeled fluorescent probes are
detected by 2 different laser light sources. |
||
|
Florescence
Energy Transfer (FRET) |
The
study of the interaction of chromophores to fluorochrome |
||
|
FRAP |
Observing
fluorescence recovery dynamics of a molecule after photobleaching. |
||
|
Sub Resolution Imaging |
Stimulated
Emission Depletion (STED) |
Resolve
images at nanometer scale. |
|
|
Ground
State Depletion (GSD) |
Excited
state molecules are driven into a dark metastable
long-lived triplet state. |
||
|
GSD and
Individual Molecule Return (GSDIM) |
|
||
|
Photoactivated Localization Microscopy (PALM) |
Single-molecule
super-resolution using optical highlighter fluorescent probes. |
||
|
Stochastic
Optical Reconstruction Microscopy (STORM) |
Single-molecule
super-resolution using photoswitchable carbocyanine dyes. |
||
|
Electron and Scanning Microscopy |
|||
|
Sub-Category |
Techniques |
Description |
|
|
Transmission
Electron Microscopy (TEM) |
Passes
electrons through the sample |
Electron
beam passes through thin slice of specimen. Resolution
limit approx 0.05 nanometers. |
|
|
Scanning
Electron Microscopy (SEM) |
Investigates
the surface of bulk objects by scanning the surface with a fine electron beam |
A 3D
view is obtained giving surface detail of specimens. Resolution
limit approx 0.4 nanometers. |
|
|
Scanning
Probe Microscopy (SPM) |
Atomic
Force Microscopy (AFM) |
High
resolution type of SFM. Resolution is in the nanometer
range. Ideal for imaging, measuring and manipulation at the nanoscale. |
|
|
Scanning
Tunneling Microscopy (STM) |
Images
surfaces at the atomic scale. Can be used in ultra high vacuum, air, water,
and other liquid or gas ambient states. |
||
|
Ultrasonic
Force Microscopy (UFM) |
Gives
detail and image contrast of flat areas of interest. |
||
|
Photonic
Force Microscopy (PFM) |
High
precision technique measuring scattered light and orientation of a particle. |
||
|
Image Analysis/Acquisition |
|
||
|
Sub-Category |
Techniques |
Description |
|
|
Digital/Analogue Analogue |
Charge
Coupled Device (CCD) |
A
scientific slow scanning device |
|
|
Electron-Multiplying
CCD (EMCCD) |
Allow
high sensitivity measurements to be taken at high frame rates. |
||
|
Scientific
Complimentary Metal-Oxide-Semiconductor (sCMOS) |
Speed
and resolution are increased for ultra low noise, fast frame rates and wide
dynamic range of cameras. |
||
|
Intensified
CCD (ICCD) |
Combine
image intensifier and CCD camera which allows for short exposure time. |
||
|
Single
Lens Reflex (SLR) Camera |
|
||
Understand the Key Features of the Technology
There are many ‘terms’ involved in microscopy, so we have selected just a few of the main key features which currently affect the majority of labs involved in image analysis, whatever your application area: (Descriptions supplied by Andor Technology.)
Detection Limit
The Detection Limit is a measure of the smallest signal that can be detected in a single readout. The smallest signal is defined as the signal whose level is equal to the noise accompanying that signal, i.e. a signal to noise ratio (S/N) of unity. Sources of noise are: Shot noise of the signal itself, Shot noise of any dark signal, Readout noise.
Image Intensifier
An Image Intensifier is a device that amplifies the intensity of an image, not the size of the image. The device is small, typically 1 to 2 inches in diameter by about 1 inch thick. An image is projected on to the input window of the device and an intensified image appears on its exit window (usually a fiber optic plate). As well as amplifying, an image intensifier can rapidly be switched on and off, allowing it to be used as a very fast shutter.
Readout
Readout is the process by which data are taken from the pixels of the CCD and stored in computer memory. The pixels, which are arranged in a single row, are read out individually in sequence. Readout involves amplifying the charge on each pixel into a voltage, performing an A/D conversion, and storing the data in computer memory. The time taken to perform this operation is known as the "read time".
Resolution
A measure of how fine a detail can be detected, in terms of either space (spatial resolution), time (temporal resolution), or intensity. The greater the resolution of the image, the more information can be determined. In fluorescence applications using low light and/or thicker specimens, confocal imaging can greatly improve resolution.
Scanning
The CCD is continually being ‘scanned’ to prevent its becoming saturated. In an acquired scan the displayed charge undergoes A/D conversion and is acquired into computer memory so that it can be used for subsequent processing and display, i.e. it is readout.
Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR)
The Signal to Noise Ratio (S/N) is the ratio between a given signal and the noise associated with that signal. Noise has a fixed component and a variable component (shot noise) which is the square root of the signal. Thus, the Signal to Noise Ratio usually increases (improves) as the signal increases. The maximum Signal to Noise Ratio is the ratio between the maximum signal (i.e. the saturation level) and the noise associated with that signal. At near saturation levels the dominant source of noise is the shot noise of the signal.
Super-resolution
The term super-resolution refers to methods that surpass the so-called diffraction limit. Applications are wide ranging – from dynamic vesicle movements in the sub-100 nm range to fluorescence images of sub-cellular structures, enabling researchers to see details only previously possible with electron microscopy.
Consider which Technology Suits your Application
As microscopy has progressed, scientists have used combinations of the above techniques to further develop this field. Confocal microscopy for example, is an optical imaging technique enabling 3D imaging of structures from obtained images. It can increase optical resolution and contrast of an image by using point illumination and a spatial pinhole to eliminate out-of-focus light in certain specimens that are thicker than the focal plane. The signal-to-noise ratio is improved in comparison to widefield techniques, and it can be used with both live and fixed specimens.
Fluorescence confocal imaging is used for live cell images. Spinning disk and Sweptfield confocal systems are ideal for the imaging of high-speed intracellular events such as calcium ion dynamics. Confocal imaging is fundamental to advanced imaging techniques such as FLIM, FRET, FRAP and FLIP and can be used in association with TIRF imaging.
TIRF is a highly sensitive technique to perform functional investigations in living cells. The high signal to noise ratio and a resolution allows the visualization and to analysis of vesicles in transport and signaling events, as well as kinetic studies and single molecules detection.
CARS microscopy for example can be used in biological, pharmaceutical, and dermatological research, biomedical imaging, food processing, and materials science. Its potential has been demonstrated for various biomedical applications, such as the imaging of lipid transport, protein concentrations, DNA, RNA, tissue in a living organism, and order in liquid crystals. By integrating CARS technology into modern optical scanning microscope systems, the researcher has the latest technology in hand combined with an easy-to-use confocal system.
The use of fluorescence in microscopy allows the more specific analysis of a specimen. Permanent coupling of fluorescence molecules with biological substances, e.g. antibodies, mean that the diagnosis of illness is becoming much more exact. Fluorescence imaging is now combined with confocal and optical methods to enhance techniques for image analysis.
Consider Your Applications:
|
Live Cell
Imaging |
Developmental
biology |
|
|
Cell
signalling |
|
|
Cell
culture and maintenance |
|
Research |
Genetics |
|
|
Neurobiology |
|
|
Electro
physiology |
|
|
Molecular
pathology |
|
|
Plant
science |
|
|
Marine
biology |
|
|
Regenerative
studies |
|
Clinical |
Cytology |
|
|
Cytogenetics |
|
|
Embryology/IVF |
|
|
Hematology |
|
|
Histology |
|
|
Immunology |
|
|
Microbiology |
|
|
Pathology |
|
|
Genitourinary |
|
|
Veterinary |
|
|
EQA |
|
Education |
Virtual
slide |
|
|
Observation
of prepared slide |
|
|
Gross
observations |
|
Pharma/Drug Discovery |
Formulation
science |
|
|
ADME tox |
|
|
Target
identification |
|
|
Cell
culture |
|
Other |
Biophysics |
|
|
Chemical
biology |
|
|
Lab-on-a-chip |
|
|
Forensic
science |
|
|
Paleontology |
|
|
Environmental
science |
|
|
Food science |
This list is not exhaustive but gives an indication of how diverse and widespread microscopy is. Consider whether your lab uses a combination of these topic areas. A microscope system that can interface with a number of these techniques may be preferable.
Manufacturers are creating systems with the ability to customize requirements. Various image analysis systems can be coupled with microscopes for specific applications. For example for live cell imaging, the primary considerations are signal-to-noise, image acquisition speed and specimen viability. Fluorescence microscopy such as TIRF, FLIM, FRAP and laser scanning, as an example, would be combined with a CCD or EMCCD for image acquisition. Researchers would look at the individual requirements of the live-cell imaging application and determine the best equipment to use following discussion with key manufacturers. Each application area is unique, however equipment can be used in different permutations to achieve individual results.
Image Acquisition – Microphotography
Acquisition of an image is obtained via either analogue methods (SLR camera, Microscope cameras) or more recently digital – CCD, sCMOS, color imaging, black and white cameras, and digital cameras. The benefit of digital cameras over the analogue counterpart is that a progressive scan output is produced which can be connected directly to a computer. The entire image is acquired during the exposure time and read out is line by line from the top of the image to the bottom. Consider the dynamic range you require in your digital solution. Manufacturers have developed solutions to enable diversity with this depending on application. No single detector will meet all the requirements of fluorescence microscopy, however consider your priorities such as exposure time, signal-to-noise. Consider your applications such as live cell imaging, single-molecule fluorescence imaging, and also consider whether you are using traditional brightfield or fluorescence microscopy to prepare the image.
The Future of Microscopy
Developments in this field are being made all the time. Microscopy is in the news regularly as scientists seek to push the boundaries and develop new techniques. Recently scientists at the University of Warwick, UK, in collaboration with a team at IBM Research, Zurich, have announced the success of imaging a molecule called ‘Pentacene’. This five linked, hexagonal ring of carbon structure was imaged with the use of scanning tunneling microscopy in conjunction with non contact atomic force microscopy to offer highly specific resolution.
Another UK based team from Imperial College, London, have combined two methods to investigate cell substrate interactions in biomedical research. A new technique developed – Light-Ion Microscopy (CLIM), combines ion and fluorescence microscopy to obtain topographical and biochemical information for the same area of a sample. Scanning ion microscopy (SIM) was developed in preference to SEM to avoid interference with the fluorescent signal.
News items such as this are regular, and our advice is to investigate the limitations and possibilities of individual equipment. Learn how to combine equipment, and how you can customize it to suit your requirements. Manufacturers produce equipment which can be upgraded, developed, and enabled to accept additional components. Think about choosing equipment which is best suited to your core requirements and develop it further from there.
Editor's picks
Kerry Parker
Editor
iXonEM+ 885 EMCCD Camera (Andor Technology)
"A very stable system with good acquisition software."
Thomas Blanpied, Univ Of Maryland School Of Medicine
Leica DMI6000 B (Leica Microsystems)
"Once you know what you are doing, this is a good product."
Ferogh Ahmadi, Millipore Corporation
QICAM Digital Camera (QImaging)
"Camera is good value, although limited for high-sensitivity applications."
Paul Jones, Arizona State University
Olympus FV1000 Confocal Microscope (Olympus)
"Great optics and images can be obtained with experience. It is excellent for limited use/limited number of users but very sensitive to breakdown with multiple users”
Victor Van Laar, University of Pittsburgh
Axio Vert.A1 (Carl Zeiss Microscopy)
"We use this microscope for all our histology needs, from H&E, to peroxidase immunohistochemistry, to immunofluorescence”
Nick Tsihlis, Northwestern University
5420 Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) (Agilent Technologies)
“The resolution is excellent and the different modes available are easy to use."
Lauren Englade-Franklin, Louisiana State University


